Mr Lupin, what would the Crimson Company do with those names if he gave the list to them instead of us?
I mean, there's no more DogStar really, or if there is that witch who ran them has been lying really low, hasn't she, but how do we know that the Company are more like DogStar? Because we carry poison, too, in case we're captured.
Anyway, I think Sam's probably not all that clever for a Ravenclaw. He ought to have shown you the list but then not handed it over. Who's to say you couldn't take that list and through them, find all the people you need? And besides that, if the Crimson Company aren't interested then he might as well give us the names and go on passing along any other secrets he thinks we ought to know.
We could give him something to tell them now and then, couldn't we? Something that might require a lot more people (are they bigger? They make it sound like they are but that could be lies), or something that we really want to make sure goes off properly so we'd tell them to stay out of it, maybe.
That might make him feel like he's more of an Order operative, maybe.
no subject
I mean, there's no more DogStar really, or if there is that witch who ran them has been lying really low, hasn't she, but how do we know that the Company are more like DogStar? Because we carry poison, too, in case we're captured.
Anyway, I think Sam's probably not all that clever for a Ravenclaw. He ought to have shown you the list but then not handed it over. Who's to say you couldn't take that list and through them, find all the people you need? And besides that, if the Crimson Company aren't interested then he might as well give us the names and go on passing along any other secrets he thinks we ought to know.
We could give him something to tell them now and then, couldn't we? Something that might require a lot more people (are they bigger? They make it sound like they are but that could be lies), or something that we really want to make sure goes off properly so we'd tell them to stay out of it, maybe.
That might make him feel like he's more of an Order operative, maybe.